We already have an existing provider…

Executive Summary

When a prospect says “we already have an existing provider”, they usually mean they’re happy enough and see no reason to talk. It isn’t a firm no. Because almost every business already has a provider, this is the most predictable objection in IT sales, which makes it the easiest one to prepare for.

  • What it means: the prospect feels no problem or desire right now, so there’s no reason to keep talking.
  • What most salespeople do: accept it and hang up, or start knocking the current provider. Neither works.
  • What to do instead: agree with them, ask whether they’d be against an alternative quote, then use it to learn about their set-up, what they like and what could be better.
  • Who this is for: MSP owners, sales leaders and salespeople who prospect by phone.


This article gives you the exact words to use, the questions that uncover real insight, and the two things to ask for before the call ends. It is the fourth and final part of our series on the most common cold call objections.

Why Do Prospects Say “We Already Have an Existing Provider”?

Most businesses you call already have something in place. Someone is looking after their IT right now, so this is the quickest way for them to end the call.

People only buy because of a problem or a desire. If they don’t feel either one when you call, they have no reason to keep talking. So they tell you they already have a provider and wait for you to go away.

The good news is that you KNOW this objection is coming. You’ll hear it more than almost any other when you sell IT services, so you have no excuse not to be ready for it.

What Are the Four Most Common Cold Call Objections?

In our experience, four responses come up far more often than any others:

  1. Send me an email
  2. I’m not interested
  3. Call me back another time
  4. We already have an existing provider

How Do Most Salespeople React?

There are three common reactions to this objection, and only one of them moves the conversation forward.

Reaction What happens Result
Give up “OK, no problem. Can I send you some information in case anything changes?” The call ends and the prospect forgets you
Attack They start telling the prospect their current provider isn’t good enough The prospect gets defensive. Nobody likes being told they made a bad decision
Get curious They agree, then ask a question the prospect finds hard to say no to A real conversation starts

What Should You Say When a Prospect Has an Existing Provider?

Agree with them, then ask a question they’ll struggle to say no to. Try these exact words:

I knew you would, you are a well-run business. Does this mean you are against getting an alternative quote? Even if it’s just to ensure you keep informed of what others in the market are doing. Would that be such a stupid idea?”

This does three things. It compliments the prospect. It shows you aren’t there to tell them they’re wrong. And it asks a question where the only reasonable answer is yes, because very few well-run businesses will say that staying informed about their own market is a stupid idea.

What Do You Do Once They Say Yes?

Don’t rush off to send a quote. This is where most salespeople blow it. They take an email address, send over a price and never hear back.

Instead, say:

“OK great, and before I give that quote to you, tell me more about your current set-up. How many users do you have?”

You’re now in a conversation rather than being shut down. From there, ask two questions:

  1. “What do you like the most about your current provider?”
  2. “What is it that you feel they could improve on?”


When they answer, PROBE MORE. Don’t take the first answer and move to the next question on your list.

If they say response times could be better, ask what happened the last time things were slow, what it cost them and how the team felt about it. If they love their account manager, ask what makes that relationship work so well.

These answers tell you what’s working, what isn’t, what frustrates them and what really matters. No amount of research on LinkedIn will give you insight like that.

What Two Things Should You Ask For Before the Call Ends?

Once you’ve built some rapport, tell the prospect you’d like to ask for two more things.

  1. The chance to share the quote on a call. Don’t just email it and hope. Ask to walk them through the quote or outline so they can be honest with you about what they think.
  2. What it would take to change. Ask:

“If you were to change, what would a new provider have to do to make you think it’s worth the change?”

The second question matters most. The prospect is now telling you, in their own words, what it would take to win their business. You don’t have to guess or pitch every feature you have. You just have to show how you’d deliver what they’ve told you matters.

What If They Still Don’t Switch?

Some won’t, and that’s fine. Your job isn’t to force everyone to change provider.

You’ll still have built a relationship and you’ll understand their set-up. And when something does go wrong (in IT, something always does), they’re far more likely to remember the person who listened than the one who hung up or criticised their choices.

What Do We See When Working With MSP Sales Teams?

At James White Sales Success, we provide outsourced sales leadership to managed service providers (MSPs). “We already have an existing provider” is the objection MSP salespeople hear most often, because almost every business they call has IT support of some kind.

The pattern is consistent. Untrained salespeople either give up straight away or try to win the argument. The ones who succeed treat the objection as the start of the conversation, and use it to learn what the prospect values and where their current provider falls short.

Frequently Asked Questions

Isn’t it pushy to keep going when they say they’re happy?

Not if you stay calm and respectful. You aren’t telling them to switch. You’re asking whether they’d be open to staying informed, which most business owners see as sensible.

Should I criticise their current provider?

No. You don’t know enough about them yet, and criticising a choice the prospect made puts them on the defensive. Ask what they like and what could improve, and let them tell you.

What if they won’t tell me anything about their set-up?

Then the interest probably isn’t there yet. Thank them for their time, and stay in touch through useful content so you’re remembered if things change.

Should I send the quote by email?

Ask to share it on a call instead. Walking them through it lets you answer questions, get honest feedback and keep the conversation going.

What’s the most important question to ask?

“If you were to change, what would a new provider have to do to make you think it’s worth the change?” The answer tells you exactly what it would take to win their business.

How do I get better at handling this objection?

Practise. Role-play it with a colleague or manager until the words feel natural, then use them on live calls and review how it went.

Want Your Team to Handle Objections Like This?

If your MSP sales team keeps losing conversations to “we already have an existing provider”, I can help.

Blog
admin

Call me back another time…

Over the last couple of weeks, I’ve covered “Send me an email” and “I’m not interested“. This week, let’s deal with another one you will

Read More »
Blog
James White

I’m not interested…

Another Saturday, another common sales objection to deal with. Last week, I covered ‘Send me an Email’, which, if you implemented the advice, will save

Read More »
Blog
James White

You Can’t Scale Without It

Executive Summary Many MSP founders are brilliant at winning business themselves but struggle when they ask other people to replicate what they do. The problem

Read More »
Blog
James White

How to build buyer trust by being honest about failure

Building buyer trust means being honest about where your service has worked, where it has fallen short and what you have changed as a result. For managed service providers selling to UK businesses, this matters because buyers are weighing up the risk of disruption, wasted investment and choosing the wrong IT partner.

Read More »